ASPIRE NOBLY 
ENCOURAGE HARMONY 
 SERVE HUMBLY 
Joey Almeida our owner-operator.

  Joey's Custard     

...Stay and Chill...

Our Motto :


Aspire Nobly

Encourage Harmony

Serve Humbly


Joey's Custard is truly a family owned and operated cafe.  We are focused on providing premium products with the highest level of customer service  – we do everything we can to make sure you,  your friends, or your family always feel welcome and leave ready to plan your next visit back with us.

With a variety of menu items to choose from, we’re sure you’ll be happy enjoying a cold treat or an espresso/ coffee with us. Debi, and her son Joey have been locals to Sanibel and Captiva since 1998, and are working to bring a place for all to come and enjoy; by offering something for everyone. Dairy-free, gluten-free, no sugar added;  we have an option for everyone. We offer indoor and outdoor seating, games, puzzles and free wifi!   So bring your laptop or a book and stay and chill...


We proudly serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream. Made in Wisconsin, with real cream and real sugar. 
This Super Premium Ice cream (14% butterfat, 35% overrun) is nationally award winning 
(18 Award Winning flavors) and is the best of the best.
 We are so proud to be working with another family business like them!

Why Choose Us?


  • Open 12-9 DAILY 
  • Indoor seating when its hot, outdoor seating when its beautiful out.
  • We work hard to please our  customers and have created a  fun and welcoming environment  to sit and enjoy. 
  • We serve it all! 

PLACE A STAR ON OUR MAP AND LET US KNOW WHERE YOU'RE TRAVELING FROM!


A FUN WAY TO SEE HOW MANY PEOPLE VISIT OUR LITTLE ISLAND EACH YEAR